More like 4.5 cool little place. Service was friendly and I really love that the shake comes in a reusable aluminum cup. Got the Sizzle burger, fries, and a shake. The burger was really good and, honestly, the buns they use look really appetizing. The shake was good too. The downsides were that the fries came out almost...overcooked? Or stale maybe. They weren't particularly hot and were crunchy in a crouton kind of way. That and my shake came out waaaay faster than my burger so it had started to thin out by the time I was starting to eat. Otherwise definitely worth stopping by, burger was really the star of the show and it's cool to see a restaurant taking steps to help environmental waster reduction.
In spite of location and burger prices I still highly recommend checking this place out. We ordered Holy Cow, Sizzle, Mister Fun Guy burgers, order of fries and poutine. Everything was super delicious. We also got peach cobbler milkshake which was excellent and huge. These guys specialize in burgers and milkshakes and they know what they’re doing. There is also a small bar where you can find a fair selection on tap and creative list of cocktails.
What’s your pleasure?? Are you interested in getting together with some friends for drinks? Then this is the place.. Or are you looking for a place to chill and have a burger and a shake? Then you might want to give this place a try. I really enjoyed the vibe of Mr. Sizzles. One side of the restaurant has a nice sized bar, and the other side a dining area. You place your order at the counter and receive a buzzer. You also can choose your own seating while you wait. The Club- BLT chicken sandwich. Decent tasting sandwich. I like the thick pieces of bacon. Fries- I love shoestring fries.. Unfortunately, my fries were dry and staked. It was obvious they were already prepared and was sitting around for sometime. Black & white- very good tasting milkshake. I knew the consistency was going to be good from seeing the big straws. I will return for another milkshake..
Stopped in for lunch on a Sunday and the place was hopping. I had the Jiffy Burger. Peanut butter and jelly and jalapenos on a perfectly prepared burger. Place your order at the counter and they buzz you when drinks are ready. Then again when your food is ready. Full service bar and a good amount of seating. They use Gifford's ice cream for their floats and shakes. I had the rootbeer float and it was excellent.
Absolutely loved this hidden Buffalo gem!! We found this place due to my sisters celiac disease. The manager personally messaged her after she put a post out looking for food in a local Buffalo FB group and explained the precautions they take and how it would be safe for her to have a burger. And she was able to enjoy a vegan milkshake as well. And my cheesy gluten filled burger was BOMB. Cannot wait to visit again.